PureBallast
UV or EC 1920x480-final

UV or EC? Reducing the investment cost for ballast water treatment

With a smart choice of treatment technology, your ballast water treatment system can save you money from the very beginning. UV treatment with Alfa Laval PureBallast 3 means less piping, fewer connections and faster, more cost-efficient shipyard work than electrochlorination (EC). See why you win with a simple, straightforward ballast water treatment technology – especially when it comes to installation.

  • Minimize system footprint
  • Avoid unnecessary vessel modifications
  • Reduce time and labour at the shipyard
  • Keep your investment cost low

Save CAPEX by reading between the lines

With a UV solution like PureBallast 3, the ballast water treatment system is closely contained – as are your costs. Electrochlorination (EC) means sprawling pipelines, plus the likely repurposing of your aft peak tank (APT) to serve as a source of salt water. Those extra metres and connections extend costs as well as footprint.

UV system (PureBallast 3)

UV system (PureBallast 3)

  • Fully integrated into existing ballast water flow
  • No use of APT – vessel can maintain trim

Full-flow EC system

EC system (full-flow)

  • Largely integrated into existing ballast water flow
  • APT and piping for salinity control
  • Stainless steel (SUS) piping for TRO and neutralization systems

Side-stream/slip-stream EC system

EC system (side-stream/slip-stream)

  • Polyethene piping for corrosive hypochlorite flow
  • APT and piping for salinity control
  • Stainless steel (SUS) piping for heating, TRO and neutralization systems
  • Piping to deck to vent hazardous gases

Choose UV treatment to avoid EC’s hidden costs

Unlike UV systems, where the ballast water simply flows through reactors that expose it to UV light, EC ballast water treatment systems require hundreds or thousands of metres of pipes. The complicated piping leads chemicals and water in and out of the ballast water treatment process, but it’s also required for chemical neutralization and sometimes as a safety measure for venting hazardous gases. The pipes extend through large sections of the vessel, especially when the aft peak tank (APT) is used to adjust salinity – which is nearly always the case.

uv-ec-costly-piping.jpg

Costly and longer piping

Unlike UV systems, where the ballast water simply flows through reactors that dose it with UV light, EC ballast water treatment systems require hundreds or thousands of metres of pipes. The complicated piping leads chemicals and water in and out of the ballast water treatment process, but it’s also required for chemical neutralization and sometimes as a safety measure for venting hazardous gases. The pipes extend through large sections of the vessel, especially when the aft peak tank (APT) is used to adjust salinity – which is nearly always the case.

uv-ec-exclusive-piping.jpg

Costly exclusive materials

The length and complexity of the piping in EC ballast water treatment systems is just the first issue. All those metres are multiplied by the material cost. Since the pipes have to withstand seawater and chemicals, many of them have to be lined with polyethene or constructed from stainless steel (SUS). Such materials can take longer for shipyards to acquire and are often far more expensive than standard materials.

uv-ec-costly-valves.jpg

More costly valves

Wherever there are pipes for multiple processes, valves are needed to steer the different flows. In an EC ballast water treatment system, there are flows for moving chemicals, heating the water, adding salinity and neutralizing total residual oxidants (TRO) – to name a few. The valves required are costly in themselves, but they’re also additional points of complexity that need maintenance and could potentially fail.

uv-ec-costly-support-components.jpg

More costly support components

Due to the piping, valves and extensive layout, an EC ballast water treatment system can be much more complicated to engineer than a UV system, which is compact and localized. Additional structures must be built to support the different parts of an EC system, which may also comprise heaters, gas detectors and other components not reflected in the supplier’s scope.

uv-ec-installation-time-cost.jpg

Installation time and costs

The more complicated a ballast water treatment system is, the more work it is for a shipyard to install it. When installing an EC system, you pay for the added complexity in two ways: the labour cost from the shipyard and the time out of service for your vessel. By choosing a UV system rather than an EC system, you can save many days of shipyard work.

uv-ec-want-deeper-understanding.jpg

Want a deeper understanding?

To learn more about the issues above and why they matter for your choice of ballast water treatment technology, be sure to download our short guide.

Comparing UV and EC investment cost

Get a quick and clear understanding of how your choice of ballast water treatment technology impacts your system investment. Our short guide explains the hidden complexities of electrochlorination (EC) systems and shows why UV solutions like PureBallast 3 are simpler and more cost-efficient when it comes to procurement and installation.

UV-vs-EC-–-comparing-investment-cost

PureBallast Mill 640x360.jpg

Shipowner insights into installation cost

Millenia Maritime Inc. has chosen UV ballast water treatment with PureBallast 3 for its fleet of MR tankers, rather than electrochlorination (EC). The choice has saved both time and money at the shipyard.

“We got very good installation results on all of our vessels, but we also secured a competitive time to market,” says General Manager Francesco Ricciardi. “In the cost-benefit analysis for the project, spending less time at the shipyard has high value. Every day the vessel is in the water is a day that it can be making money.”


Read the full story

Contact us to discuss the choice of UV or EC

Your choice of technology may be the most important one you make in ballast water management. We’d be happy to discuss it with you, in brief or in depth.


Contact us here

pureballast-contact-vignette.jpg